EdChoice Moves to Defend West Virginia’s Education Savings Account Program
West Virginia parents step in to protect universal access to school choice program
Press Release: For Immediate Release
Tuesday, November 3, 2026
EdChoice Moves to Defend West Virginia’s Education Savings Account Program
West Virginia parents step in to protect universal access to school choice program
INDIANAPOLIS — On behalf of West Virginia families, EdChoice Legal Advocates (EdLA) has filed a motion to intervene as defendants in the lawsuit brought by eleven Mingo County parents against the state’s recently expanded education savings account (ESA) program.
The Hope Scholarship, enacted in 2021, has nearly doubled in size since it became available to all West Virginia students this school year. It provides an average of about $5,435 annually to over 26,000 students via education savings accounts which may be used to pay for tuition, tutoring, curriculum, therapies, and other qualified educational expenses. The state legislature originally made the program available only to kindergarteners or students switching from public school, but the law allowed the program to expand once certain enrollment figures were met.
In September, opponents filed a lawsuit challenging the program’s expansion of eligibility to all West Virginia students.
“West Virginia made a commitment to educational freedom when it expanded the Hope Scholarship to all students. Tens of thousands of families across the state are now relying on that promise,” said Thomas M. Fisher, Executive Vice President and Director of Litigation at EdChoice Legal Advocates. “We look forward to defending Therese and Nicole as they fight to preserve their families’ access to this life-changing and entirely constitutional program.”
EdLA is asking the court to allow two West Virginia families whose children are using Hope Scholarships to formally join the case and defend the constitutionality of the program.
Therese Crowley lives in Martinsburg, where she homeschools her four children, each receiving a Hope Scholarship. Two of her children just became eligible for Hope with this year’s expansion. Her children range from kindergarten to sixth grade, and all are neurodivergent and not adequately served by a traditional school setting. The ESAs have allowed Therese to purchase a homeschool curriculum tailored to her children’s unique learning styles, and already they have significantly improved their math and reading skills and been able to expand into activities that boost fine motor skills. Hope is also funding other supports for Therese’s children including speech therapy, and she is also exploring occupational therapy for her daughter.

Without the scholarship program, Crowley would likely have to take an additional job to afford her children’s dyslexia, speech, and autism assessments as well as their therapies and educational activities, which would also cause her to lose homeschooling time. Losing the scholarships would be a major financial burden for her family.
Nicole Maddock, also of Martinsburg, is a mom of two boys, a third grader who is homeschooled and a seventh grader who attends a Christian school. Both boys became eligible for Hope Scholarships this school year with the expansion. Maddock and her husband moved their family to West Virginia in part specifically so their sons could take advantage of Hope. Nicole’s older son has dysgraphia and a sensory processing disorder and experienced anxiety attacks in public school, which also did not offer the gifted programs he needs to reach his full potential as a high intelligence student. Their younger son was not ready for private school and so continues to thrive as a homeschooler this year. The family uses the ESAs to afford their older son’s tuition and their younger son’s homeschool curriculum, supplies, and activities. Without the program, they might have to pull their older son out of the school where he is thriving and cut back on curriculum and activities for their younger son.
Learn more about the case:
To be connected with Thomas Fisher or one of the clients, contact Mairead Elordi at [email protected].
EdChoice is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, nonpartisan organization. Our mission is to advance educational freedom and choice for all as a pathway to successful lives and a stronger society. We are committed to understanding and pursuing a K–12 education ecosystem that empowers every family to choose the learning environment that fits their children’s needs best. Learn more at edchoice.org.
###